.png)
Select Home Warranty has stayed true to its mission of protecting homeowners, buyers, and sellers.
4.5 RentalWarrantyTrustScore
Is Select Home Warranty Worth It?
Select Home Warranty provides budget-conscious landlords with affordable warranty coverage starting at $44-48 monthly, approximately 14% below industry averages. Operating since 2012, the company offers three specialized plans with free roof leak coverage and competitive service fees of $75-100. However, coverage limits are notably low at $500 for most appliances and systems, with mixed customer reviews averaging 2.4/5 on Trustpilot, making it suitable primarily for newer rental properties with lower repair risk expectations.
Coverage Options
Select offers three plans - Bronze Care (appliances only), Gold Care (systems only), and Platinum Care (comprehensive). Free roof leak coverage included with all plans, though coverage caps are low at $500 for most items except HVAC ($3,000 limit).
Pricing
Highly competitive pricing with plans starting $44-63 monthly and $75-100 service fees. Regular promotions offer significant discounts including free months and annual payment savings, making Select one of the most affordable options available.
Customer Service
Mixed customer feedback with 1.49/5 BBB rating but 3.8/5 on ConsumerAffairs. Customers praise helpful sales representatives and customization options, but frequently cite contractor quality issues, claim denials, and delayed service responses as major concerns.
Claims Processing
24/7 claim submission available online and via mobile app with 48-hour technician assignment promise. Extended 60-day workmanship guarantee exceeds industry standard, though customer reviews indicate frequent claim denials and contractor reliability issues.
Select Home Warranty Pros & Cons
Pros
Most affordable plans in warranty industry
Free roof leak coverage with plans
Extended 60-day workmanship guarantee periods
Cons
Low $500 coverage caps most items
Mixed customer reviews and service quality
How do I know I can trust this Select Home Warranty review?
This Select Home Warranty review is built on extensive research methodology specifically designed for rental property investors and landlords. Our comprehensive evaluation process analyzes verified customer feedback across multiple review platforms, detailed examination of service contracts and coverage limitations, and thorough comparison with industry benchmarks for rental warranty providers. We focus on factors most critical to property investors: cost-effectiveness for budget-conscious landlords, reliability for maintaining tenant satisfaction, and coverage adequacy for rental property protection. Our research incorporates direct consultation with property management professionals and real estate investment experts to ensure recommendations address the unique financial and operational challenges facing rental property owners. This specialized, rental-focused methodology ensures our review provides dependable guidance for landlords seeking affordable warranty protection while understanding the associated limitations and trade-offs.
See Plans →Select Home Warranty Review Overview
Select Home Warranty delivers solid coverage with unique add-ons for specialized rental property needs, though service consistency varies. Protect your rental investment with Select Home Warranty's comprehensive plans today.
| Platinum | Gold | Bronze | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A/C, Cooling | Yes | Yes | No |
| Ceiling Fan | Yes | No | No |
| Clothes Dryer | Yes | No | Yes |
| Clothes Washer | Yes | No | Yes |
| Cooktop | Yes | No | Yes |
| Dishwasher | Yes | No | Yes |
| Ductwork | Yes | Yes | No |
| Electrical System | Yes | Yes | No |
| Garbage Disposal | Yes | No | Yes |
| Heating System | Yes | Yes | No |
| Microwave Oven (Built In) | Yes | No | Yes |
| Plumbing Stoppage | Yes | No | No |
| Plumbing System | Yes | Yes | No |
| Stove/Oven | Yes | No | Yes |
| Water Heater | Yes | Yes | No |
| Garage Door Opener | Yes | No | No |
| Refrigerator | Yes | No | Yes |
Optional Coverage Add-Ons
Select Home Warranty provides eight optional add-ons to enhance your base warranty coverage beyond standard plan inclusions. These additional protections allow landlords to customize coverage for specific rental property features while maintaining the company's focus on affordability.
Select Home Warranty Pricing
Select Home Warranty positions itself as one of the most affordable warranty providers in the market with competitive pricing structures designed for budget-conscious homeowners. Bronze Care and Gold Care plans start at $44-48 monthly (approximately $57 without discounts), while the comprehensive Platinum Care plan costs around $63 monthly. Service fees range from $75-100 per technician visit, which is competitive within the industry. Annual payment options provide substantial savings with customers receiving up to two free months plus additional discounts, making total annual costs range from $479-699 depending on plan selection and available promotions. Select frequently offers new customer promotions including $150 discounts and extended free coverage periods, making it particularly attractive for cost-sensitive rental property investors.
| Platinum | Gold | Bronze | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | As low as $756/year | As low as $576/year | As low as $528/year |
| Service Fee | $75-$100 | $75-$100 | $75-$100 |
Prices are estimates, do not include any additional coverage add ons, and can vary based on location and other variables.
How Select Home Warranty Compares to Other Home Warranties
Select Home Warranty competes in the rental warranty market primarily on price point, offering some of the most affordable coverage available though with correspondingly lower coverage limits and mixed service reviews. While Select's $500 coverage caps for most items are significantly lower than premium competitors, the inclusion of free roof leak coverage and competitive service fees provide value for landlords managing newer properties or those with limited warranty budgets. Understanding how Select measures against other rental warranty options helps property investors balance cost savings against coverage limitations.
| Select Home Warranty | Choice Home Warranty | First American | American Home Shield | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average annual premium | $420/year to $660/year | $476–$660 | $450–$570 | $450–$570 |
| Add On Coverage Available | Yes | 15,000 in-network | In-network (number not specified) | In-network (number not specified) |
| Service call fee | $75-$100 | $75–$85 | $60 | $60 |
| Service requests | Service requests can be submitted online or by phone, 24/7 | Service requests can be made online or by phone, 24/7 | Service is available by phone, 24/7 | Service is available by phone, 24/7 |
| American Home Shield Review | First American Review | Liberty Home Guard Review |
Select Home Warranty FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)
This site offers free content and comparison tools for consumers. We may receive
compensation from featured companies, but aim to provide objective comparisons.
Listings do not imply endorsement, and we don’t cover all providers.
Prices may change — visit providers websites for the latest rates.
Mailing Address:
Houston, Texas USA
© 2025 RentalWarranty.com All rights reserved.