Last Updated September 2025

Best Rental Warranty Company Reviews

Our in-depth reviews of the top rental warranty providers covers the industry leading providers of home warranties. Check out our expert insights today.

Find the best plan through a no obligation quote
Build just for rental properties to be trusted for landlords, property managers, & other real estate pros

Choice Home Warranty

4.5 RentalWarranty TrustScore

Choice Home Warranty offers comprehensive coverage for rental property systems and appliances with flexible plan options. Known for their straightforward claims process and nationwide service network, they provide landlords with reliable protection against unexpected repair costs. Their competitive pricing and responsive customer service make them a solid choice for rental property investors.

Home Warranty of America

4.5 RentalWarranty TrustScore

Home Warranty of America delivers dependable coverage for rental properties with customizable plans tailored to landlord needs. Their extensive contractor network ensures prompt service calls, while their transparent pricing structure helps property owners budget effectively. With decades of industry experience, they offer reliable protection for both residential systems and major appliances.
Home Warranty of America Logo

The Home Service Club

4.5 RentalWarranty TrustScore

The Home Service Club specializes in affordable home warranty solutions designed for rental property management. Their streamlined claims process and 24/7 customer support provide peace of mind for landlords managing multiple properties. With comprehensive coverage options and competitive service fees, they focus on minimizing downtime and repair expenses for rental investments.

American Home Shield

4.5 RentalWarranty TrustScore

American Home Shield is one of the largest home warranty providers, offering extensive coverage for rental properties nationwide. Their vast contractor network ensures quick response times, while their established reputation provides reliability for property investors. Multiple plan tiers allow landlords to customize coverage based on property age, size, and specific protection needs.
American Home Shield Logo

Liberty Home Guard

4.5 RentalWarranty TrustScore

Liberty Home Shield provides flexible warranty solutions specifically designed for rental property owners and real estate investors. Their competitive pricing, combined with comprehensive system and appliance coverage, helps landlords protect their investments while maintaining tenant satisfaction. Quick claims processing and reliable contractor partnerships ensure efficient property maintenance and repairs.
Liberty Home Guard Logo

Select Home Warranty

4.5 RentalWarranty TrustScore

Select Home Warranty offers budget-friendly protection plans ideal for rental property portfolios. Their straightforward coverage options and transparent pricing help landlords make informed decisions about property protection. With reliable customer service and an established contractor network, they provide essential coverage for systems and appliances without complicated terms or conditions.
Select Home Warranty Logo

First American Home Warranty

4.5 RentalWarranty TrustScore

First American Home Warranty brings decades of industry expertise to rental property protection, offering comprehensive plans backed by a trusted brand. Their efficient claims process and quality contractor network ensure reliable service for landlords. Multiple coverage tiers and add-on options allow property owners to customize protection based on individual rental property requirements.
First American Home Warranty Logo

This site offers free content and comparison tools for consumers. We may receive
compensation from featured companies, but aim to provide objective comparisons.
Listings do not imply endorsement, and we don’t cover all providers.
Prices may change — visit providers websites for the latest rates.

Mailing Address:

Houston, Texas USA

© 2025 RentalWarranty.com All rights reserved.